Series episode
Cast: (24 - show/hide all)
| Kathryn Morris | ... | Lilly Rush |
| Danny Pino | ... | Scotty Valens |
| John Finn | ... | John Stillman |
| Jeremy Ratchford | ... | Nick Vera |
| Thom Barry | ... | Will Jeffries |
| Samantha Eggar | ... | Sister Vivian Dole (2003) |
| Garrett M. Brown | ... | Roger (2003) |
| Molly Cheek | ... | Gretchen Culliver (2003) |
| Bruce Gray | ... | Dr. Milton Thayer (2003) |
| Charles Noland | ... | Walter Rafferty (2003) |
| Autumn Reeser | ... | Sister Grace Ashley |
| Jacqueline Scott | ... | Sally Bower (2003) |
| Lyndon Smith | ... | Arnold Culliver |
| Johanna Watts | ... | Sister Vivian Dole (1958) |
| Jason Frasca | ... | Young Man (1958) |
| Andrew Heald | ... | Roger (Cowboy) (1958) |
| Gathering Marbet | ... | Young Woman (1958) |
| Blaire Restaneo | ... | Gretchen Culliver (1958) |
| Justin Roney | ... | Fred (Indian) (1958) |
| Brent Schraff | ... | Dr. Milton Thayer (1958) |
| Ryan Tasz | ... | Clayton Weathers (1958) |
| Delaney Williams | ... | Fred Calvin (2003) |
| Christian Hutcherson | ... | Orphan |
| Dave Michael Beaudrie | ... | Walter Rafferty |
Crew:
| Karen Gaviola | ... | Direction |
| Meredith Stiehm | ... | Script |