| James Hiroyuki Liao | ... | Jay Lee (7 episodes) |
| Tawny Cypress | ... | Cherie Rollins-Murray (7 episodes) |
| Carol Commissiong | ... | NYPD Officer (6 episodes) |
| Deanna Dunagan | ... | Alice (5 episodes) |
| Gregg Micheals | ... | Pedestrian
(5 episodes) |
| Ray DeForest | ... | NYC detective (4 episodes) |
| Rick Bolander | ... | M.C.S. Tech
(4 episodes) |
| Victoria Leigh | ... | Young Carrie (3 episodes) |
| Haley Murphy | ... | Rachel (3 episodes) |
| Khari Wyatt | ... | Keith (3 episodes) |
| Jackson Hurst | ... | Steve Cioffi - Jr. (3 episodes) |
| James Urbaniak | ... | Richard Simmons (3 episodes) |
| Samira Wiley | ... | Gina (2 episodes) |
| Kyle Beltran | ... | Henry (2 episodes) |
| Madison Arnold | ... | Mr. Wanamaker (2 episodes) |
| Elli | ... | Rabbi Elli (2 episodes) |
| Mike Houston | ... | Erik Newsome (2 episodes) |
| Annie Parisse | ... | Elaine Margulies (2 episodes) |
| Omar Metwally | ... | ADA Adam Gilroy (2 episodes) |
| Edwin J. Birmingham | ... | ESU Commando (2 episodes) |
| Steven Anderson | ... | Police Artist (2 episodes) |
| Liam Ferguson | ... | NYPD Crime Scene Detective (2 episodes) |
| Dennis Rees | ... | Construction Worker
(2 episodes) |
| Jill Paice | ... | Molly Benedict (2 episodes) |
| Omar Chagall | ... | Mr. Cruz (2 episodes) |
| Edward M. Kelahan | ... | Mob Driver (2 episodes) |
| Adam Trese | ... | Krause (2 episodes) |
| Emily Shaffer | ... | Andrea (2 episodes) |
| Stephen Kunken | ... | Dale Parsons (2 episodes) |
| Rafael Benoit | ... | Twenty-Something 1 (2 episodes) |
| Makenzie Leigh | ... | Celine Emminger (2 episodes) |
| Tom Guiry | ... | Ken Harbert (1 episode) |
| Roxanna Hope | ... | Wendy Wilson (1 episode) |
| Brian O'Neill | ... | Frank Harbert (1 episode) |
| Andrew Katz | ... | Norman (1 episode) |
| Timothy Adams | ... | Steve Latman (1 episode) |
| Ezra Knight | ... | Hank Sturgis (1 episode) |
| Vanessa Aspillaga | ... | Jill (1 episode) |
| Temur Mamisashvili | ... | Isaac (1 episode) |
| Robert Vataj | ... | Jerry (1 episode) |
