| Allison Miller | ... | Carrie (13 episodes) |
| Bill Cobbs | ... | George (8 episodes) |
| Hayes MacArthur | ... | Wyatt (5 episodes) |
| Piper Perabo | ... | Simone (5 episodes) |
| Terrell Owens | ... | Himself (4 episodes) |
| Christine Woods | ... | Janie (4 episodes) |
| Erin Hammond | ... | K-Ball Receptionist (3 episodes) |
| Jonny Beltran | ... | Coffee Shop Patron / Wedding Guest (2 episodes) |
| Lauren Benz Phillips | ... | Becca (2 episodes) |
| Vanessa Bell Calloway | ... | Joyce (2 episodes) |
| Ethan Herisse | ... | Nate (2 episodes) |
| Haley Tju | ... | Abby (2 episodes) |
| Alexander George | ... | Random Patron (2 episodes) |
| Jennifer Jalene | ... | Producer (2 episodes) |
| Rich Eisen | ... | Himself (2 episodes) |
| Khary Payton | ... | Don (1 episode) |
| Matt Knudsen | ... | Jack Madden (1 episode) |
| Kevin Garnett | ... | Himself (1 episode) |
| Kimrie Lewis-Davis | ... | Terrell's Girlfriend (1 episode) |
| Angelica Pulido | ... | Iris (1 episode) |
| Keelin Woodell | ... | Sophie (1 episode) |
| Lilli Passero | ... | Reina (1 episode) |
| Ian Jensen | ... | Maitre'd (1 episode) |
| Nikki Smith | ... | Hair stylist (1 episode) |
| Alejandro Patino | ... | Miguel (1 episode) |
| Charles Carpenter | ... | Tim (1 episode) |
| Timothy Ryan Cole | ... | Waiter (1 episode) |
| Jeremy Roenick | ... | Himself (1 episode) |
| Erin Foley | ... | Fawning Woman (1 episode) |
| Jessica Manuel | ... | Lady Skater (1 episode) |
| Dan Moriarty | ... | Player (1 episode) |
| Alison Robertson | ... | Sasha (1 episode) |
| Devin Sidell | ... | Woman in Blue (1 episode) |
| Shane Brady | ... | Featured Hockey Player (Team Blue) (1 episode) |
| Jennifer Birmingham | ... | Mindy (1 episode) |
| Robert Parks-Valletta | ... | Guy (1 episode) |
| Jerry Hauck | ... | Proctor (1 episode) |
| Ross Mackenzie | ... | Man (1 episode) |
| Holly Walker | ... | Clerk (1 episode) |
| Paul Diaz | ... | Hector (1 episode) |
