| Dale Raoul | ... | Andrea Grinnell (11 episodes) |
| Jolene Purdy | ... | Dodee Weaver (10 episodes) |
| Eddie Cahill | ... | Sam Verdreaux (10 episodes) |
| Karla Crome | ... | Rebecca Pine (10 episodes) |
| Grace Victoria Cox | ... | Melanie Cross (10 episodes) |
| John Elvis | ... | Ben Drake (8 episodes) |
| David Pascua | ... | Chester's Mill Resident (7 episodes) |
| Joe Montanti | ... | Mad Towns Folk (7 episodes) |
| Samantha Mathis | ... | Alice Calvert (6 episodes) |
| Sherry Stringfield | ... | Pauline Rennie (6 episodes) |
| Beth Broderick | ... | Rose Twitchell (5 episodes) |
| Crystal Martinez | ... | Nurse Adams (5 episodes) |
| Dwight Yoakam | ... | Lyle Chumley (5 episodes) |
| R. Keith Harris | ... | Peter Shumway (4 episodes) |
| Ned Bellamy | ... | Rev. Lester Coggins (4 episodes) |
| Leon Rippy | ... | Ollie Dinsmore (4 episodes) |
| Andrew Vogel | ... | Carter (4 episodes) |
| Rochelle Aycoth | ... | Nurse (4 episodes) |
| Mary-Jo Jackson | ... | Chester's Mill Townsperson (4 episodes) |
| William Frasca | ... | Chester's Mills Looter (4 episodes) |
| Steve Baldwin | ... | Diner Patron (3 episodes) |
| Lemuel Heida | ... | Pedestrian (3 episodes) |
| James Alcorn | ... | Young Junior (3 episodes) |
| Chris Sepulveda | ... | Townsfolk (3 episodes) |
| Natalie Zea | ... | Maxine Seagrave (3 episodes) |
| Joseph Milton Hodges Jr. | ... | Chester's Mill Townsfolk (3 episodes) |
| Joseph Milton Hodges Sr. | ... | Chester's Mill Townsfolk (3 episodes) |
| Nancy Rouse Hodges | ... | Chester's Mill Townsfolk (3 episodes) |
| Mary Austin | ... | Chester's Mill Townsfolk (3 episodes) |
| Estes Tarver | ... | Tom Tilden (3 episodes) |
| Max Ehrich | ... | Hunter (3 episodes) |
| Brett Cullen | ... | Don Barbara (3 episodes) |
| Wil Smith | ... | Chester's Mill Resident
(3 episodes) |
| Jeff Fahey | ... | Sheriff Duke Perkins (2 episodes) |
| Josh Carter | ... | Rusty (2 episodes) |
| Sherrie Bowling | ... | Diner Patron (2 episodes) |
| Alexia Stip | ... | Town Person (2 episodes) |
| Kevin Sizemore | ... | Paul (2 episodes) |
| Paul Shaplin | ... | Big Jim's Army (2 episodes) |
| James Nass | ... | Patient (2 episodes) |
